These Greek and Cypriot cakes, pies and pastries all have one thing in common: syrup goes over them after baking. Some are custard pies with crisp phyllo, some are soft semolina or yogurt cakes, and one is a walnut-filled finger pastry. You can choose by texture and by how much time you have.
If you're feeding a crowd, galaktoboureko or the lemon phyllo pie will cover it. For a simple cake with coffee, the lemon yogurt cake and kalo prama use pantry basics. The orange almond cake has no flour, so it suits anyone avoiding gluten, as long as the baking powder is gluten-free too.
Most of these taste better the next day, so you can bake ahead. Cut small pieces, because they're sweet.
Choosing what to make
The biggest difference between these desserts is the syrup. Galaktoboureko gets cool syrup, the honey cake gets cold syrup on a hot cake, and the lemon phyllo pie gets hot syrup on a hot pie. The other cakes and daktyla take warm syrup while the pastry is still hot. Check each method before you start so the cake doesn't turn dense or soggy.
The custard pies need the most patience, with a few hours of setting time. The semolina and yogurt cakes are the easiest, mostly one bowl and one small pot. Daktyla takes the most hands-on work because you roll each pastry. The orange almond cake needs a long, mostly hands-off boil first.
1. Galaktoboureko Custard Pie with Lemon-Cinnamon Syrup

This is the one to make when you need a dessert for a crowd. Semolina custard is cooked on the stove, then baked between buttered phyllo in a 23 x 33 cm / 9 x 13 inch dish. The custard is soft and just sweet enough, and the top is flaky. Store-bought phyllo keeps it simple, so there is no dough to roll. The cool lemon and cinnamon syrup goes on as soon as the pie comes out of the oven. Then you need to wait about 3 hours for it to set, or the custard runs. It makes 12 squares and keeps in the fridge for up to 3 days.
Wait the full 3 hours before cutting, then serve neat squares cool or at room temperature with coffee.
Get the Galaktoboureko Custard Pie with Lemon-Cinnamon Syrup recipe
2. Portokalopita: Greek Orange Phyllo Cake, Soaked in Syrup

Portokalopita is a good way to use up half a package of phyllo. You tear the sheets into small pieces and let them dry out for a bit. Then you mix them into an orange custard batter with Greek yogurt, oil and orange zest, all in one bowl. After baking, warm orange syrup goes over the top and soaks all the way through. The cake is soft and moist, with a few crisp phyllo edges. The dry phyllo matters, because fresh, moist pieces make the middle gummy. It tastes even better the next day, once the syrup has settled in.
Serve squares the next day with a spoonful of plain Greek yogurt to balance the sweet orange syrup.
Get the Portokalopita: Greek Orange Phyllo Cake, Soaked in Syrup recipe
3. Kalo Prama: Cypriot Semolina Cake with Sweet Syrup

Kalo Prama means good thing in Greek, and it is a Cypriot semolina cake with coconut and cinnamon. It has a soft, spongy crumb that takes in syrup without turning mushy. You bake it in a 9×13-inch pan and pour the warm lemon syrup over the cake while it's still hot, so the syrup soaks in evenly. Use fine or medium semolina, because coarse stays gritty. You only need a couple of bowls and a small saucepan. It keeps at room temperature for several days and is even better the next day, so it's an easy one to plan ahead.
Cut it into small squares, since it's rich and sweet, and serve with strong black coffee.
Get the Kalo Prama: Cypriot Semolina Cake with Sweet Syrup recipe
4. Baked Greek Honey Cake with Walnuts and Lemon Syrup

This is a simple semolina cake that still feels a little special. The batter has olive oil, yogurt and orange zest, and you make it in one bowl. The syrup is honey and lemon, and the honey is the main flavor, so use one you like. Toasted walnuts on top add crunch and a slight bitterness that balances the sweetness. The key detail is temperature: the syrup needs to be cold when it goes over the hot cake. If both are warm, the cake turns dense instead of light. The crumb stays sticky and soft for days.
Toast the walnuts in a dry pan first, then serve slices with plain yogurt and a small drizzle of extra honey.
Get the Baked Greek Honey Cake with Walnuts and Lemon Syrup recipe
5. Soft Greek Lemon Yogurt Cake with Lemon Syrup Soak

If you want a cake for a Sunday afternoon, start here. It's made with olive oil and full-fat Greek yogurt, so the crumb is soft and fine. It tastes bright and a little tangy. You bake it in a 23 cm / 9-inch round pan, poke holes across the top with a skewer, then pour warm lemon syrup over the hot cake. The holes help the syrup soak all the way through. It needs two bowls, no frosting, and travels well. A fruity extra virgin olive oil shows up in the flavor, while a milder oil keeps it quieter.
Cut it into wedges and bring it to a friend's house, or serve with coffee and no topping at all.
Get the Soft Greek Lemon Yogurt Cake with Lemon Syrup Soak recipe
6. Golden Baked Lemon Phyllo Pie with Custard Filling

This pie is close to galaktoboureko, but I lean harder into the lemon, both in the custard and in the syrup. The semolina custard is made with milk, eggs and plenty of zest, and it sets thick and a little bouncy, not runny. Phyllo on the top and bottom bakes crisp, then softens slightly under the syrup. The syrup goes on hot, right when the pie comes out of the oven. Cold syrup on a cold pie just sits on top. You can make it a few hours ahead and leave it at room temperature, which helps for a dinner party.
Make it a few hours ahead, then cut thin squares and serve at room temperature with tea.
Get the Golden Baked Lemon Phyllo Pie with Custard Filling recipe
7. Cypriot Carob Syrup Cake: Sticky, Spiced, and Simple

This olive oil cake is sweetened mostly with carob syrup instead of white sugar. The color is deep brown, and the flavor is closer to dates or molasses than cocoa. Orange and cinnamon balance the earthy taste, and walnuts add some crunch. You mix the batter in one bowl with a whisk, and the semolina gives a slightly coarse crumb that takes in syrup well. Look for Cypriot or Greek carob syrup, sometimes labeled harnup. Date syrup works in a pinch but tastes sweeter. It's best made a day ahead so the syrup has time to sink in.
Serve a slice with plain yogurt and an extra spoonful of carob syrup on the side.
Get the Cypriot Carob Syrup Cake: Sticky, Spiced, and Simple recipe
8. Flourless Cypriot Orange and Almond Cake

Here you boil whole oranges until soft, then blend them, peel and all, into a batter with ground almonds, eggs and sugar. There's no flour, so the cake is moist, dense and a bit sticky, closer to a pudding than a sponge. The flavor is bright with a slight bitter edge from the peel, and a simple syrup goes over the cake while it's warm. The oranges boil for about 90 minutes, but it's mostly hands-off. If you need it gluten-free, check your baking powder label. The orange flavor gets stronger by the next day.
Slice it thin and serve it plain with coffee, or add a little Greek yogurt on the side.
Get the Flourless Cypriot Orange and Almond Cake recipe
9. Cypriot Daktyla Pastries with Walnuts and Syrup

Daktyla are small filo fingers filled with chopped walnuts, cinnamon and a little orange zest. Each one is rolled into a short plump log, not layered like baklava. They bake until golden and crisp, then go into honey-lemon syrup while still hot. Don't drown them, or the layers turn mushy. Chop the walnuts finely, but not into powder, so the filling keeps some texture. Keep the filo covered with a damp towel while you work so it doesn't crack. They are less rich than a tray of baklava, and you can freeze them before baking.
Pack them in a single layer in a box to bring to a friend's house, since they travel well.
Get the Cypriot Daktyla Pastries with Walnuts and Syrup recipe
Planning your menu
- Check the syrup temperature in each method before you start. Some pastries need hot syrup on a hot pie, and the honey cake needs cold syrup on a hot cake.
- If you're serving a crowd, pick one custard pie and one cake. Galaktoboureko or the lemon phyllo pie gives you creamy squares, and a semolina or yogurt cake gives you something drier to balance them.
- Bake ahead where you can. Portokalopita, kalo prama, the honey cake, the carob cake and the orange almond cake all taste better the next day.
- Cut small pieces. These desserts are sweet, so a small square with strong coffee or plain tea is usually enough.
- Thaw phyllo or filo in the fridge overnight, and keep unused sheets under a damp towel so they don't crack.
For a relaxed dessert table, set out one custard pie, one simple cake and a plate of daktyla. Cut everything into small pieces, and add a bowl of plain Greek yogurt and a pot of strong coffee. Bake the cakes the day before, and keep the custard pie for the morning so it has its full time to set.
Frequently asked questions
Should the syrup be hot or cold when you pour it on?
It depends on the recipe, so follow the method. The general rule is to pour cooler syrup over a hot cake or pie, and the honey cake especially needs cold syrup. The lemon phyllo pie is the exception, with hot syrup on a hot pie. Matching the temperatures this way helps the syrup soak in without making the crumb dense.
Can I make Greek syrup cakes a day ahead?
Yes, and most of them improve overnight. Portokalopita, kalo prama, the honey cake, the carob cake and the orange almond cake all taste better the next day once the syrup has settled in. Galaktoboureko can bake a day ahead too and keeps in the fridge for up to 3 days.
What is the difference between galaktoboureko and lemon phyllo pie?
They are very close. Both have semolina custard between crisp phyllo layers and a syrup soak. Galaktoboureko uses a cool lemon-cinnamon syrup and needs 3 hours to set, while the lemon phyllo pie leans harder on lemon in the custard and takes a hot syrup poured onto the hot pie.
Which fine or coarse semolina is better for cakes?
Fine semolina is the safer choice for most cakes and custards. It gives a smoother crumb and blends into custard without gritty bits. Kalo prama also works with medium semolina, but coarse semolina can stay gritty even after the syrup soaks in, so I avoid it for these desserts.
Which of these desserts are gluten-free?
The flourless Cypriot orange and almond cake is the only one made without flour, so it's the natural choice. If you need it fully gluten-free, check your baking powder label, since some brands contain gluten. The phyllo pies and semolina cakes all contain wheat.
