6 Olive Oil Cakes and Cookies Made Instead of Butter

These olive oil cakes and cookies all skip the butter, and they're easy to make. Four are cakes and two are cookies. Most need just a bowl and a whisk, so there's no mixer and no waiting for butter to soften. The oil keeps the crumb soft for days, which makes them good to bake ahead.

I use a fruity extra virgin olive oil in all of them. You'll taste it, so pick one you like and avoid anything very bitter or peppery. Citrus shows up a lot here because it keeps the sweets fresh instead of heavy.

Each pick has its own flavor, from orange and pistachio to fig and walnut, so you can match one to the fruit or the time you have.

Choosing what to make

The four cakes differ mostly in flavor and effort. The orange pistachio loaf and the fig walnut cake have nuts for crunch, while the lemon rosemary cake is more herbal and the plain orange cake is the quickest, with everything in one bowl. Fig walnut is the seasonal one, best when fresh figs are around. The two cookies are different too. The lemon shortbread is crisp at the edges and sandy inside, and you chill the dough first. The ladokouloura are soft and a little cakey, shaped by hand, and they keep well for a week. If you only want to bake one thing, start with the one-bowl orange cake.

1. Moist Orange Olive Oil Cake with Toasted Pistachios

Sliced orange olive oil loaf with glaze and chopped pistachios on a wooden board

This is a loaf-style cake with orange zest and juice, plus toasted pistachios folded into the batter. I like it when I want something for coffee that isn't too sweet. The oil keeps the crumb moist for days, and the orange stops it from tasting heavy. Use a fruity extra virgin oil you'd happily drizzle on a salad, because it does most of the flavor work. You mix the wet and dry ingredients in two bowls and fold them together. The glaze is optional, but I like the extra citrus, and it helps the pistachios on top stay put.

Toast the pistachios while the oven heats, then let the cake cool before glazing so the glaze sets and holds the nuts.

Get the Moist Orange Olive Oil Cake with Toasted Pistachios recipe

2. Fragrant Lemon Rosemary Olive Oil Cake with a Glaze

Glazed lemon rosemary olive oil cake with one slice cut and fresh rosemary beside it

A simple round cake with lemon zest and finely chopped rosemary mixed right into the batter, then topped with a lemon glaze. It tastes bright and a little herbal, and it isn't very sweet. You bake it in a 9-inch (23 cm) pan, and two bowls and a whisk are all you need. Chop the rosemary fine so nobody bites into a woody piece. If you need it dairy free, oat milk works in place of whole milk and the texture stays close. Choose a mild oil, since a very peppery one can taste sharp.

Wrap a few slices to take to a friend's house. It travels well, and a sprig of rosemary on top makes it look finished.

Get the Fragrant Lemon Rosemary Olive Oil Cake with a Glaze recipe

3. Rustic Fig and Walnut Olive Oil Cake with Honey Glaze

Honey-glazed fig and walnut olive oil cake with a wedge cut and fresh figs nearby

Fresh figs and toasted walnuts go into a round cake baked in a 9-inch pan, then a little honey goes on top. It's rich but not heavy, with soft pockets of fig and a bit of crunch from the nuts. I'd make it in early fall when figs show up at the market. If your figs are very ripe and juicy, pat them dry before folding them in, or the center can turn wet. Pick figs that are ripe but still firm so they hold their shape. Bake time is about 45 minutes.

Warm the honey for a few seconds so it spreads instead of pooling, and serve with coffee at breakfast.

Get the Rustic Fig and Walnut Olive Oil Cake with Honey Glaze recipe

4. Soft Orange Olive Oil Cake with Fresh Orange Glaze

Round glazed orange olive oil cake with two slices cut on a white plate

This is the simplest of the cakes. Everything mixes in one bowl with no mixer, and you finish it with a glaze of orange juice and powdered sugar. Don't worry if the batter looks thin before baking. It turns into a tender, even cake. Zest the oranges before you juice them, and spoon the flour into the cup instead of scooping so the cake doesn't turn dense. Pick this one over the pistachio loaf when you want fewer steps and a plain, soft slice that keeps well for a few days.

Serve a slice after dinner with a scoop of plain yogurt, or with coffee in the morning.

Get the Soft Orange Olive Oil Cake with Fresh Orange Glaze recipe

5. Lemon Olive Oil Shortbread with Crisp Sugared Edges

Sugared-edge lemon olive oil shortbread cookies with a lemon half and dough log

These are shortbread cookies made with olive oil as the only fat, plus lemon zest and juice in the dough. The edges turn pale gold and crisp, and the center stays soft and short. There's a faint fruity note from the oil under the lemon. You whisk the oil and sugar, fold in the flour, roll the dough into a log, and chill it. Rolling the log in sugar gives the sparkly edge. The recipe has no eggs or dairy, and the cornstarch keeps the crumb tender.

Make the dough log ahead and keep it chilled, then slice and bake a few cookies whenever you want tea.

Get the Lemon Olive Oil Shortbread with Crisp Sugared Edges recipe

6. Ladokouloura: Greek Olive Oil Biscuits with Orange

Twisted Greek olive oil biscuits with sesame seeds beside coffee and a halved orange

Ladokouloura are Greek olive oil biscuits shaped into twisted ropes or rings, flavored with orange juice, zest, and a little cinnamon. They're soft and a little cakey, closer to a slice of olive oil cake than a crisp cookie, and they aren't very sweet. The dough comes together in one bowl with a whisk, and you shape each cookie by hand. Cloves are strong, so measure them carefully. A light coating of sesame seeds adds crunch, but you can skip it. The cookies stay soft for close to a week.

Dunk them in coffee or tea. I like to freeze some of the dough so I can bake just a few at a time.

Get the Ladokouloura: Greek Olive Oil Biscuits with Orange recipe

Planning your menu

  • Choose a fruity, mild extra virgin olive oil. Very bitter or peppery oils can taste sharp once baked, and you'll notice it in cookies especially.
  • Zest citrus before you juice it. It's much easier to zest a whole orange or lemon than a squeezed half.
  • Bake the cakes a day ahead for a gathering. The oil keeps the crumb moist, and you can glaze just before serving.
  • For a mixed dessert plate, pair one cake with one cookie, such as the fig walnut cake with ladokouloura, so you get soft and crisp with different flavors.
  • Spoon flour into the measuring cup and level it off. Packed flour makes both the cakes and the cookies dense or dry.

If I'm putting out a simple spread for coffee, I bake one cake and one cookie, then slice the cake thin. Orange pistachio cake with a few lemon shortbread cookies on the side gives you a soft bite and a crisp one, and nothing needs butter. Keep a pot of strong coffee or tea nearby, and set out any leftover fruit from the recipes, like orange wedges or fresh figs.

Frequently asked questions

Can I replace butter with olive oil in any cake or cookie recipe?

Not always one for one. Butter adds water, solids, and structure, so a straight swap can change the texture. It's safer to use recipes written for olive oil, like the ones here, where the other ingredients are already balanced. Use a fruity extra virgin oil, since you'll taste it in the finished bake.

What kind of olive oil is best for baking cakes and cookies?

Pick a fruity, mild extra virgin olive oil that tastes good on its own. Since the oil is the main fat, its flavor comes through. A very bitter or peppery oil can taste sharp once baked, and a cheap, flat oil can make the cake taste like very little.

How long do olive oil cakes stay moist?

They stay moist for days, because oil keeps the crumb soft better than butter does. Keep a cooled cake covered at room temperature. If it has a glaze or fresh fruit, like the fig walnut cake, eat it sooner and keep an eye on it. The same goes for cookies like ladokouloura, which stay soft for close to a week.

Can I make olive oil cookies ahead of time?

Yes. The lemon shortbread dough can be rolled into a log and chilled, then sliced and baked later. The ladokouloura dough can be frozen so you can bake a few cookies at a time. Baked cookies also keep at room temperature, so a batch is easy to make before guests arrive.

Which of these olive oil cakes is easiest for a beginner?

Start with the soft orange olive oil cake. It's made in one bowl with a whisk, needs no mixer, and the batter is forgiving even when it looks thin. Spoon the flour into the cup instead of scooping, zest the oranges before juicing them, and let the cake cool before glazing.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *